Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Is Israel a strategic liability for the United States?

Michael F. Scheuer:

Israel is not only an unnecessary and self-made liability for the United States, it is an untreated and spreading cancer on our domestic politics, foreign policy, and national security. America has no genuine national security interests at stake in either Israel or Palestine; if they both disappeared tomorrow the welfare of Americans and the security of their country would not be impacted a lick. The Arab-Israeli religious war is a war that properly belongs solely to Israelis and Arabs; let them fight each other to the death with no interference in favor of either side from the United States. The continued, automatic, and idiotic identification of U.S. national interests as identical with Israel's made by our bipartisan political elite, the media, and those U.S. citizens who prefer Israeli to American security is only earning Americans deeper hatred and more wars with Muslims. There is no question that Israel has every right in the world to militarily defend itself to whatever extent it deems necessary, but neither Israel, the United States, nor any other nation has a "right" to exist. Nation-states survive if they can vanquish their enemies. The democratically elected Israeli government is right to try to vanquish Hamas; and the democratically elected Hamas regime has every right to try do the same to Israel. The point to keep squarely in view is that it does not matter to America's security who emerges the winner.

Related:

Scheuer: Israel needs suicide bombers to commit Obama to Israel's religious war

Bringing the Arab-Israeli War Home

Rationalizing Gaza

GAZA – BOMB THEM BACK TO THE STONE AGE

Will Israel never learn? Each bomb is a gift to its enemies

If I were Israel’s PM. . .

It breaks my heart to see Israel's stupidity

MIKE SCHEUER INTERVIEW

What if Egypt, Jordan, and Syria had won the Six Day War?

No comments: